Employer Monitoring: How to Comply With Data Protection Law

The Information Commissioner’s Office (ICO) has released guidance for employers to help understand legal compliance surrounding workplace monitoring and data protection.

Workplace monitoring can include various activities, including tracking calls, messages, keystrokes, screenshots, webcam footage, audio recordings, or specialised monitoring software.

The ICO’s research reveals that 70% of the public deems employer monitoring intrusive, emphasising the need for organisations to balance business interests with the privacy rights of their workforce. The guidance, applicable to both public and private sectors, highlights the importance of conducting monitoring lawfully, transparently, and fairly.

With nearly one in five people believing they have been monitored by an employer, the ICO’s guidance becomes pivotal in establishing a framework that respects workers’ privacy. The rise of flexible working has heightened concerns about monitoring encroaching into personal spaces, making transparency and fairness imperative for building trust.

If you are considering moving to a hybrid or flexible working pattern or would like tips on monitoring hybrid staff fairly, listen to our podcast episode on managing hybrid workers.

Is It Lawful to Monitor Staff?

The ICO’s research brings to light significant concerns and perceptions regarding workplace monitoring. Over two-thirds of respondents (70%) find workplace monitoring intrusive, and less than one in five (19%) would be comfortable taking a new job if monitoring were involved. The findings emphasise the delicate balance employers must strike to ensure a positive work environment that respects employee privacy.

While data protection law doesn’t outright prohibit the monitoring of workers, it necessitates adherence to specific requirements to ensure compliance. Article 8 of the Human Rights Act 1998 talks about the right to respect for private and family life, a consideration that gains prominence with the increasing prevalence of remote work.

The home environment, in particular, demands careful consideration, as workers’ expectations of privacy are likely higher at home than in a traditional workplace. It’s essential for employers to recognise the risks associated with capturing information about workers’ families and private lives when monitoring them in a home setting.

The key to legality lies in conducting monitoring activities consistent with data protection law. Balancing business interests with workers’ rights and freedoms is crucial when deciding to implement monitoring measures. Unfair monitoring practices not only impact workers’ rights and freedoms under data protection law but also erode trust between employers and employees, potentially affecting mental well-being.

The availability of monitoring tools doesn’t automatically make them the best choice, employers must clearly define their purpose and opt for the least intrusive means to achieve their objectives.

Monitoring Compliance

The ICO advises organisations to do the following when complying with data protection regulations:

  • Inform workers: Make employees aware of the nature, extent, and reasons for monitoring.
  • Purpose: Clearly define the purpose of monitoring and use the least intrusive means to achieve it.
  • Lawful basis: Ensure a lawful basis for processing workers’ data, such as consent or legal obligation.
  • Transparency: Communicate any monitoring in an easily understandable way.
  • Relevance: Only retain information relevant to the monitoring’s purpose.
  • Impact assessment: Conduct a Data Protection Impact Assessment for monitoring with a high risk to workers’ rights.
  • Subject Access Requests (SARs): Make collected information available to workers upon request.

As the world of work evolves, so does the need for responsible workplace monitoring. The ICO’s guidance serves as a roadmap for employers, emphasising the importance of respecting privacy while leveraging necessary monitoring practices.

Contact us to schedule your complimentary consultation.

West Wing, Greenhill House, Thorpe Road, Peterborough, PE3 6RU

01733 217 690